I've been talking about business logic flaws in my last few stories. Time for a deep dive.

In the past months, I've written extensively about various cybersecurity challenges. But there's one type of vulnerability that keeps coming up in real attacks. Business logic flaws.

These aren't your typical SQL injections or XSS attacks. They're different. More insidious.

What Are Business Logic Flaws?

Business logic flaws happen when applications work exactly as coded. But the logic itself is broken.

No error messages. No crashes. The system functions normally.

Yet attackers can manipulate legitimate features to achieve unintended results.

Real Example: The Coupon Code Disaster

Consider an e-commerce site offering 20% off coupons. Normal flow:

  1. Customer adds items to cart
  2. Applies coupon code
  3. Gets discount
  4. Completes purchase

An attacker discovers the API doesn't validate coupon usage limits. They apply the same code multiple times. Each request stacks another 20% discount.

Result? A $100 item costs $0.32 after five applications.

The system works perfectly. The business loses money.

The Attacker Mindset

Step 1: Map the Business Flows

Attackers don't start with code analysis. They understand the business first.

They ask:

  • What workflows generate revenue?
  • Where are approval processes?
  • What assumptions drive the logic?

Step 2: Question Every Assumption

Developers assume users behave predictably. Attackers exploit these assumptions.

Common flawed assumptions:

  • Users follow steps sequentially
  • Input comes only through the UI
  • One session equals one user
  • Past actions can't be reversed

Step 3: Identify State Manipulation Points

Business logic depends on state transitions. Attackers look for ways to manipulate these states.

Examples:

  • Skipping payment verification
  • Accessing admin functions with user privileges
  • Triggering workflows out of order

Common Attack Patterns

If you're finding this useful, please give it a few 'claps' and share it with your network! Your support helps this content reach more people.

Pattern 1: Workflow Bypass

Normal login flow:

  1. Enter credentials
  2. Verify 2FA
  3. Access granted

Attack: Direct API call to step 3, skipping verification.

Pattern 2: Parameter Tampering

An order API accepts:

{
  "userId": 12345,
  "productId": 678,
  "price": 99.99,
  "role": "customer"
}

Attacker modifies:

{
  "userId": 12345,
  "productId": 678,
  "price": 0.01,
  "role": "admin"
}

Pattern 3: Race Conditions

Multiple simultaneous requests exploit timing windows.

Example: Redeeming the same gift card multiple times before the first transaction completes.

Detection Strategies

Manual Testing Approach

  1. Map all user journeys
  2. Identify decision points
  3. Test unexpected sequences
  4. Manipulate parameters
  5. Look for privilege boundaries

Automated Detection

Business logic flaws resist traditional scanners. New AI-powered tools like Escape and Wallarm show promise.

Key capabilities:

  • Understanding application context
  • Simulating real user behavior
  • Detecting workflow violations

Real-World Impact

The USPS Incident (2018)

A business logic flaw in USPS's Informed Delivery API allowed any authenticated user to access other users' data. 60 million records exposed.

The flaw? Missing access control validation in the API endpoint.

Coinbase's $250,000 Bug (2022)

A validation gap let users trade cryptocurrencies using balances from different assets. The logic allowed impossible transactions.

Coinbase's response: Fixed immediately and awarded a massive bounty.

Prevention Best Practices

Design Phase

  • Model all business rules explicitly
  • Document assumptions
  • Consider abuse cases
  • Plan for edge scenarios

Development Phase

  • Validate on server-side always
  • Implement proper state management
  • Use workflow engines
  • Apply principle of least privilege

Testing Phase

  • Include business logic in security reviews
  • Test with attacker mindset
  • Verify all state transitions
  • Challenge every assumption

The Future Challenge

Business logic attacks are evolving. AI helps attackers analyze workflows faster. They discover flaws in minutes that once took hours.

Traditional security tools lag behind. They focus on technical vulnerabilities, not business logic.

The solution? Security teams must think like attackers. Understand the business. Question assumptions. Test workflows from an adversarial perspective.

Key Takeaways

Business logic flaws are invisible to most security tools. They exploit legitimate functionality rather than code bugs.

Success requires understanding the business context. Map workflows. Identify assumptions. Test edge cases.

Remember: If the logic is flawed, perfect code won't save you.

Follow me for more cybersecurity insights. I share practical techniques from the trenches of application security and system administration.